Use the same method and the same email you used last time. Almost every login problem turns out to be a switch between Google, Facebook, and the emailed magic link, or a second email address.
Steps
Start with the sign-in method you used before.
Check the address. A different email points at a different account, even when both belong to you.
If you sign in by email, request a fresh magic link and open it within the hour. Older ones stop working.
Nothing in your inbox? Look in spam first.
Good to know
There's no password to reset, because Wishpicks doesn't do email-and-password login. When a magic link stops working, the fix is a new link, or going in through Google or Facebook instead.
Google and Facebook logins that share one email address land in the same account. If they use different addresses, you'll end up somewhere other than where you expected.
Your account is tied to the email you signed up with and can't be swapped in Settings, so signing in with a new address gets you a new, empty account rather than your old one.
Still locked out? Contact support and tell us which method and which email you tried. We answer on business days, so weekend and holiday messages get picked up the next working day.
Related
"I didn't receive an email — what now?"
"How do I change my email or profile name?"